It's all about to have your own opinion. I can see your points and I even agree with most of them but I still like the game. On the other hand I couldn't get into GoW 3... Camera and controls were like wtf for me so I immediately dropped. Ye I could have invested more time into this game and it would have probably got better over time but for some reason I just didn't want to... Of course that doesn't mean that I think that the game is bad, complete opposite!
There are more games like nioh, bloodborne etc. which I don't like (that try hard to get past something and you just keep dying...).
Well... What I'm trying to say is that everyone should have their own opinion and we should respect it.