[PS4 platinum/Haven Historian]

There seems to be some issue with the percentages shown after each chapter. I played through the game on PS4 (prior to release) and managed to get the platinum without any issues. The percentages were a little bit off though, or showed weird numbers. That didn't impact any of the trophies in my experience. 

[Trophy Thoughts?]

2 hours ago, liammill18 said:

Word of warning, many trophies are currently broken. I finished the game last week and many trophies did not award. Check out my profile (at time of writing) to see how I’m missing a variety of story trophies despite having finished the game.

Oof. I had one of the story based trophies not popping the first time around. I'm currently stuck with echoes and Thomas notes not tracking at all, either in activity cards or simply grabbing them all. Tried the classic tricks - deleting save, starting a new, deleting/redownloading. No clue why they're not tracking :/

[Trophy Thoughts?]

10 minutes ago, breakingthegreen said:

Can someone who speaks Xbox tell us if we'll need a guide, and whether there's chapter select.

No chapter select. Plenty of missable collectables / echoes / memory shards. 

[Clear & Unfinished Trophies]

14 minutes ago, Demortuus said:

Steam Community :: Guide :: I Saw Black Clouds Achievements (WIP 14/15)
Comment 30 and 31

Nice, glad to see my instructions worked out for you. Was hoping someone would try them out and verify they worked before I posted them here as well.

[Clear & Unfinished Trophies]

Help is not bugged, it just requires _very_ specific choices to be made to ensure you end up on the Surgeon path while still believing in ghosts. 
(and some choices after that). It's a really, really finicky one to get, but it is doable.