Xylobe

Making a few changes to my planned list-- I expected to finish Atelier Rorona this month and leave Fall Guys for next, but it's looking like the opposite will be the case. Also found a viable option for #4. 0 - Darksiders Genesis (10210) 1 - Assassin's Creed Brotherhood [PS4] (5551) 2 - Persona 5 Royal [EU] (10572) 3 - Stardew Valley (5673) 4 - Control [PS5, NA] (12184) 5 - Atelier Meruru Plus: The Apprentice of Arland (2115) 6 - Atelier Lulua: The Scion of Arland (9136) 7 - NieR Replicant (617) 8 - Sakura Wars (10128) 9 - Fall Guys (11209) Atelier Rorona Plus: The Alchemist of Arland (2729)

For me the trophy popped a bit after I hit level 50 fame and just before my 20th win.

Season 4.5 just started last week, so next season won't be until mid-July.

In other words, we agree that there are other confounding variables that influence a trophy's rarity. Why, then, are you still saying that rarity equals effort?

This is exactly what people are taking issue with in the first place-- it's inconsistent with official Sony statistics and it's inconsistent with every other statistic on this site. The problem isn't that we need a way to accurately estimate the number of DLC owners, the problem is that the number of DLC owners doesn't matter in the first place. Even if we knew the exact numbers for every DLC for every game, using them rather than the number of base game owners would still buck convention in all the wrong ways.

I've been playing the PS3 version of Atelier Rorona Plus recently. It, like many games in the Atelier series, also has a "DX" release on PS4. The Plus and DX versions of the game are identical in both content and trophies, but the former has a 6% platinum rate, and the latter nearly 22%. If a trophy's rarity is an indication of how much effort it takes to obtain, how can it vary that wildly between two releases of the same game?

This, this, and this. Only 3 of my 9 UR plats I would describe as having any mechanical difficulty at all; the other 6 were either longer games or were niche PS+ games that most people dropped. This site takes DLC trophies into account for completion statistics. PSN itself takes DLC trophies into account for completion statistics. Whether or not you own the DLC could not matter less in either case. If you own the game and don't have the trophies, then you own the game and don't have the trophies. If you're concerned about trophies that are "too easy" being shown as "too rare," it doesn't mean the solution is to pull numbers out of a hat-- it means you don't understand what rarity is. It's been said before that trophy/achievement hunting as a whole is more about free time and disposable income than gameplay ability, and that becomes more and more true the further up the leaderboard you look. You can already go out and buy more platinums than you can shake a stick at-- why is the sanctity of the Ultra Rare something that needs to be artificially protected?

Once they decide you've shown sufficient evidence, they'll do whatever needs doing on their end and the missing trophies will pop on the main menu the next time you start the game.

Button Bashers, and yeah, it's terrible. I win pretty much every time because it's such a poorly thought out and explained game that my opponents never understand the objective until I have too much of a lead to come back from. That said, the worst games BY FAR in my opinion are the Season 3 team games, Pegwin Pursuit and Snowy Scrap.

Chipset got replaced today with the legendary Disc Diva set and the legendary Carbon Fibre pattern, hence the thread.

Glad to see this is happening again this year! I'm in again, with a tentative list: 0 - Darksiders Genesis (10210) 1 - Assassin's Creed Brotherhood [PS4] (5551) 2 - Persona 5 Royal [EU] (10572) 3 - Stardew Valley (5673) 4 - ??? 5 - Atelier Meruru Plus: The Apprentice of Arland (2115) 6 - Atelier Lulua: The Scion of Arland (9136) 7 - NieR Replicant (617) 8 - Sakura Wars (10128) 9 - Fall Guys (11209) Several longer games on here, but after last summer's Tales marathon I think I can manage!

Top row items are the same for everyone

Took like 36 hours from my initial email, but they got around to unlocking all four trophies for me. I'm surprised at the quick responses others are getting.