Shadow of the Colossus
Shadow of the Colossus • Reason: Mighty Wander (stamina) was earned before Stalwart Wander (HP). Players can earn Stalwart Wander on the first playthrough compared to the ~4 playthroughs to earn Mighty Wander Even if avoiding the +HP fruit boosters, a player might max HP on their second playthrough -- a whole two playthroughs before maxing stamina.
First of all I would like to mention that I am not a native english speaker despite I am using an US account. So any mistakes in grammar or misunderstandings, please do not blame me. I will try my best to explain why I should be unflagged for this game. I´m from Germany by the way.
As the flag above says, I am flagged for the game „Shadow of the Colossus“ for the trophy „Stalwart Wander“ (Max out HP bar) after earning „Mighty Wander“ (Max out stamina bar).
I do not know who flagged me for this but this person stated a false reason:
Both bars need exactly the same amount of colossi to be defeated and approximately the same amount of fruits / lizards to be collected. I knew at that time, in order to collect all fruits for the trophy „Cornucopia“, I need a maxed out stamina bar and I have to climb on top of the shrine to collect the last forbidden fruits.
What I did was: I collected all of the lizards in my second playthrough of the game leaving the fruits completely ignored for the time being. After I received the trophy for a maxed out stamina bar, I started collecting all of the fruits in my fourth playthrough. And as I stated before, both bars need approximately the same amount of „EXP“ if you want to call like that. With the fruits uncollected the whole time playing this game I reached maximum stamina before maximum HP.
As I am writing this text I looked up other disputes for this game, but unfortunately none of these were being flagged for the same reason as I do. I can ensure you I didn´t use any cheats or savegames for all of my 350+ games in my list.
I can offer you a voice chat via PS4 for discussing this dispute or other games in my list more thoroughly because writing these texts is taking me too much time because I am not a native english speaker. I am very sure you look at all of my games trying to find more illegal earned trophies (hint: Persona 4 Arena for PS3 and BioShock Infinite from the BioShock Collection for PS4).
I have nothing hide and I am not going to hide anything. I am no cheater and I earned all of my 15,000+ trophies legit.
Greetings from Germany,