RomanClaret's Dispute

[Rezzua 59]

RomanClaret

FIFA 09

 

This trophy is going way back, though if I remember correctly that trophy popped when I was playing standard online Head-to-Head matches. I know I'd won way more than 5 Interactive league matches within the period that mode was live, though I believe if you won matches by DNF then it didn't seem to pop the trophy as the games had to be completed without the opponent quitting for it to register. So completing full matches on the server in H2H mode later down the line afterwards triggered it to pop for some reason, I've no control over the EA server for a trophy popping.

 

I've no foul play on my account at all, so I'm quite deflated that after all these years of fair gaming I've been flagged up for a single trophy. If I could have any trophies on my account unlock, then it would be the unobtainable one on FIFA 10 which has stopped my from earning the only FIFA platinum I do not have. But it's unobtainable, that's life and you get on with it and play new games. I have no motive or reason to earn trophies illegitimately, for the 8 years that I've been trophy hunting. I've never hidden games either on my time on PSNP because I've never had anything to hide. I apologise if this is a long-winded response and it's only meant to be vague, but I've never been accused of cheating therefore I'm being as informative and transparent as I possibly can.

Edited April 9, 2017 by RomanClaret
Information did not post properly.

[ScooloV 89]

Just hide it and return to leaderboard.

There is no way you can get trophy in December 2010, that was unachievable since 3rd June 2009 (https://psnprofiles.com/trophies/72-fifa-09/RomanClaret?order=date - btw you got it last before platinum, that's also really interesting).

[Rezzua 59]

Well I guess I just have to hide it then if it means being put onto the leaderboards. If it was unobtainable since '09, then how have so many people got trophy from 2010 onwards and are not flagged as well?

 

https://psnprofiles.com/trophy/72-fifa-09/46-real-world-winner

[MMDE 6,300]

2 minutes ago, RomanClaret said:

Well I guess I just have to hide it then if it means being put onto the leaderboards. If it was unobtainable since '09, then how have so many people got trophy from 2010 onwards and are not flagged as well?

 

https://psnprofiles.com/trophy/72-fifa-09/46-real-world-winner

 

I think there are people reporting them atm. Did you say this out of feeling differently treated or as evidence it was possible?

[ScooloV 89]

It is not fast process, all of them will be flagged sooner or later. There are ~1k cheated FIFA 09 and flagging each of them manually takes time.

[Rezzua 59]

2 minutes ago, MMDE said:

 

I think there are people reporting them atm. Did you say this out of feeling differently treated or as evidence it was possible?

Just now, ScooloV said:

It is not fast process, all of them will be flagged sooner or later. There are ~1k cheated FIFA 09 and flagging each of them manually takes time.

 

I linked that latest earners lists as I clicked the trophy after I saw my flag description about 2009 and noticed numerous people had earned it in 2010, so I was just curious as to why they are on there. I know it's a manual process so it takes time, but if I'm having to resort to putting a blue 'H' on my profile because of this game then I wanted clarification that the other players in the latest earners are also having to do that.

[Pricey403 15]

So are we assuming the people being flagged in 2010 are all hackers? It could be as Roman said, and that EA messed up as usual and the trophy could glitch pop. Hell, there's even evidence of this from when the mode was up, as shown from this link - http://www.xboxachievements.com/game/fifa-09/achievement/19083-Real-world-winner.html

Yes, now that the online is completely shut down you can assume that everyone else is using another method to get there, but if the online was still up, bad coding could force a pop

[crash 46]

Hmm. I noticed the last achiever was 20^th Nov 2013 3:20:59 AM.

 

Now this obviously looked suspicious given that the latest one before that was 17th Oct 2010 1:35:49 PM, you can see there are loads of other achievers that have this trophy in 2010, now if this were 'hackable' surely there would be a plethora of more achievers after that date? It drops off a cliff after 2010 which makes no sense to support the argument that this was hacked.

 

It's not unheard of for trophies that go by server side requirements to 'glitch' and pop at a another time date which given the amount of achievers after it was apparently unobtainable seems definitely possible for hear and the crap load of other achievers in 2010.

Edited April 9, 2017 by CaptainSellers

[TheManUtdFan 23]

Also just to add, the whole trophy being glitchy because of DNFs adds up too- this was a problem with all the older FIFAs.

http://www.playstationtrophies.org/forum/fifa-09-a/58494-people-keep-quitting.html

Edited April 9, 2017 by FeXcEz-_-Sk1lLzz

[ScooloV 89]

All non-2010 achievers were reported long time ago, because of server closure (this 2013 is a fresh profile, some "wannabe trophyhunter" with hacked trophies).

 

There was a glitch in Real world winner (all guides speak about it), it's when you need to win more than 5 matches in order to get this trophy, that's it.

 

And there is no other way, rather than using save-hack to earn it after 3rd June 2009. I already gave a lot of prooflinks on previous disputes, you can even find them by yourself by just googling.

 

11 minutes ago, CaptainSellers said:

if this were 'hackable' surely there would be a plethora of more achievers after that date

There were, I just reported them all one by one...

Edited April 9, 2017 by ScooloV

[HallawMickey 22]

Ill also reitterate what has been said above in the fact that it popped well after the requirements were met due to the server tracking stats. The issue has been around in many other fifa games but because this happened to pop at a slightly over ambiguous time it's apparently hacked via game saves. Doesn't make any sense, like Roman has mentioned why would he bother hacking this when he could of just got the fifa 10 platinum alongside it and have all the platinums?

 

It's an invalid and very nit-picked dispute that has more than enough substance behind it to have the flagging removed. This was a glitch due to the poor netcode and not a game save mod e.t.c. Roman is an extremely trustworthy and honest person, if one game was hacked then why not a few more? This is a totally wasted flagging dispute and someone just picking apart a profile for the sake of it.

[crash 46]

nevermind

Edited April 9, 2017 by CaptainSellers

[ScooloV 89]

http://web.archive.org/web/20150512105538/https://psnprofiles.com/trophy/72-FIFA-09/46-Real-world-winner - you can see the amount of achievers through time. All of them, who had it after Feb 2011 were just reported.

 

UPD: btw RomanClarets hid the Fifa 09 and returned to leaderboard.

Edited April 9, 2017 by ScooloV

[diskdocx 1,151]

58 minutes ago, ScooloV said:

It is not fast process, all of them will be flagged sooner or later. There are ~1k cheated FIFA 09 and flagging each of them manually takes time.

 

I'm going to throw my support with RomanClaret on this, who I have known for quite a while. He has a ton of other incomplete games - who hacks one trophy?

 

If there are really more that 1000 cheaters on FIFA 09, then either you have your information wrong, or it is the most hacked game ever?

 

Usually with hacks there are oddities with the time stamps, and typically if people are using downloaded saves, the trophy dates are more clustered. There are daily, or near daily earners of the Real World trophy throughout 2010. I simply don't believe this would be the case if these were all hacked.

[turpinator1986 238]

Yeah I'm gonna throw my opinion in behind this one. Something just doesn't add up. I've seen it happen on other games before where online trophies have popped wayyyyyy after they should have because of a dodgy server. I'm not defending anyone in particular but this specific trophy it seems there could be more to it than meets the eye. 

[ScooloV 89]

You have any other information rather than your thoughts of disbelief? I gave plenty of proofs and yeah, all this years this trophy was completely ignored by everyone (I don't know why), and now there are ~1k cheaters out of 146k game owners (which makes less than 1%). I think it is not "most hacked game ever", not even close.

Imagine noone banned EndWar cheaters or FUEL etc. and then they suddenly began to do it. That'd make even more than 1k and much more that 1% in total. I think I just found Klondike of easy flag reports and that's it 😉

 

P.S. Give me one proof of legal Real world winner trophy (earned in 2010), just one, a video or whatever, not asking for much.

Edited April 9, 2017 by ScooloV

[RachP13 3,520]

I'm going to support RomanClaret with this one too, even though I don't know him personally.

 

It seems entirely feasible to me that the trophy popping later could be due to server side net coding, having played some of the Fifa games on Xbox I can certainly see how this would be possible.  I'd like to hear from more people who have unlocked the trophy, to fully understand their experiences, as essentially people who are entirely innocent could be flagged in error here.

[Pricey403 15]

8 minutes ago, ScooloV said:

You have any other information rather than your thoughts of disbelief? I gave plenty of proofs and yeah, all this years this trophy was completely ignored by everyone (I don't know why), and now there are ~1k cheaters out of 146k game owners (which makes less than 1%). I think it is not "most hacked game ever", not even close.

Imagine noone banned EndWar cheaters or FUEL etc. and then they suddenly began to do it. That'd make even more than 1k and much more that 1% in total. I think I just found Klondike of easy flag reports and that's it 

 

P.S. Give me one proof of legal Real world winner trophy (earned in 2010), just one, a video or whatever, not asking for much.

We have given plenty of proof back of the trophy originally being glitched and the fact that EA servers aren't exactly the best backs this up. For x amount of valid earners to suddenly be "hackers" just seems odd, especially only for a single game as well. 

 

I don't know how you expect us to give you proof for a game released in 2009 that now has closed servers. Roman's response is proof, and as Rach says, others being flagged can most likely give the same reasoning as well

Edited April 9, 2017 by Pricey403

[ScooloV 89]

He hid it = he agreed that it was hacked. End of story.

Edited April 9, 2017 by ScooloV

[Rezzua 59]

Just now, ScooloV said:

He hid it = he agreed that it was hacked. End of story.

 

How is me hiding it agreeing that I have hacked it? I have hidden it because I have been forced into a corner to do so, so that I remain on the PSNP leaderboards and can still partake in other forum activities (such as PST) which I have been doing for years.

[Pricey403 15]

1 minute ago, ScooloV said:

He hid it = he agreed that it was hacked. End of story.

Or he was forced into hiding it? If he unhides it now, and it's proven legit, then all of the other flags can be proven legit as well?

[HallawMickey 22]

1 minute ago, ScooloV said:

He hid it = he agreed that it was hacked. End of story.

He hid it so he could get back on the leaderboard, not to satisfy you. Please take the time to evaluate things going on around you, scouring leaderboards making claims for no reason other than bragging rights is a complete waste of time

[ars 231]

People hiding disputed trophy lists in order to restore default site functions is to restore those site functions. It's not agreeing into anything.

[ScooloV 89]

The direction of this discussion leads to a dead end. Let's wait for @grimydawg

[RachP13 3,520]

Out of curiosity, have you played Fifa 09 @ScooloV?

 

As you seem to be the one flagging people on Fifa 09, I thought maybe you could share your personal experiences of the servers.  It would at least help to have some additional insight and input here.