NBA Live (All-Star edition) for $6 or NBA 2K19 for $20

[djb5f]

I am getting the itch to get back into an NBA series (despite a backlog of other games).  I was looking at NBA Live All-Star edition for $6, it has a glitched trophy that hasn’t been earned since early October so no platinum there unless they getting around to fixing.  

 

Then I was thinking why not pay $20 for NBA 2K19 as I enjoyed this series before.  I wouldn’t necessarily plan to get the Platinum in this either but who knows.

 

Anyone played both?  I read Live upped the fun factor but my guess is Ultimate Team is a mess and not done as well as My Team.  Shame there are no Domination trophies, I enjoyed playing through those and helped with coins for other MyTeam trophies.

 

NBA 2K19 worth the extra money?

Edited February 14, 2019 by djb5f

[kidson2004]

As someone who owns both, go with 2K. For some reason the mechanics on 2K feels much better than on Live 19. I do plan on going back to play live, but I like the character progression system better on 2K. Plus for less than $20, it’s the perfect price and time to pick it up.

[Lordguwa]

the glitched trophy soured it for me. they said for years they would fix that toy soldiers game but never did. going to go with the 20$ game.

[djb5f]

Trophies seem easier (esp. the Golds) for NBA Live but yeah, I am leaning to 2K.  I want the best gaming experience to go with it.