Is This The Right Thing to Do? Help

[DeathlessVoid]

I have all the achievements for this game on PC, but for some reason this trophy for PS4 is giving me a particularly difficult time.

 

So far I have:

 

1. Said Yes to Mary
2. Give tape to Bill
3. Told Brea No about loving Mary

4. Didn't shoot Mark or Nelson
5. Slept with Brea

 

1. Said Yes to Mary

2. Give tape to Bill

3. Told Brea No about loving Mary

4. Didn't shoot Mark, shot Nelson

5. Slept with Brea

6. Reloaded, didn't sleep with Brea

 

This is the last achievement I need, so I've obviously done other combinations and this still isn't unlocking. Probably on my 6th or 7th playthrough at this point.

Edited October 17, 2019 by HumanAbandonware

[DeathlessVoid]

Finally got it after a bunch of trial and error.

 

1. Tell Mary your story (Yes).

2. Give tape to Bill (Yes).

3. Tell Brea you love Mary (Yes).

4. Do not shoot Mark.

5. Shoot Nelson.

 

Trophy pops once you get inside Dave's house.