Made in New Haven trophy won't pop

[clowve]

Playthroughed twice and still not popping. The first time (no guide & offline) I was thorough and got all the fyrestone side quests and got every ! on the map. Only Made in Fyrestone popped.

 

Second playthrough I followed a guide and hosted the whole session in public where other players could drop in, followed a checklist, and still nothing. I did ignore all Fyrestone missions this time. I've done everything up until the final boss. Not sure what I'm doing wrong here. 

 

Can I not wrap up missions and then switch to another mission to turn them in on a later time? Does it not pop that way? Or do I have to do the mission, complete it, turn it in (in that order) and only then start a new one?

Edited August 26, 2020 by clowve

[funboy1246]

i hope not. generally i've been doing a handful of missions and turning them all in at once.

[ATTYYYYY487]

1 hour ago, clowve said:

Playthroughed twice and still not popping. The first time (no guide & offline) I was thorough and got all the fyrestone side quests and got every ! on the map. Only Made in Fyrestone popped.

 

Second playthrough I followed a guide and hosted the whole session in public where other players could drop in, followed a checklist, and still nothing. I did ignore all Fyrestone missions this time. I've done everything up until the final boss. Not sure what I'm doing wrong here. 

 

Can I not wrap up missions and then switch to another mission to turn them in on a later time? Does it not pop that way? Or do I have to do the mission, complete it, turn it in (in that order) and only then start a new one?

Handing masses in at a time shouldn't make a difference. You saved all claptrap etc?

[clowve]

5 minutes ago, Top-Lad-Luke said:

Handing masses in at a time shouldn't make a difference. You saved all claptrap etc?

Yeap, I made sure to get every one of them. The Fully Loaded trophy popped for me. At my wits end here

28 minutes ago, funboy1246 said:

i hope not. generally i've been doing a handful of missions and turning them all in at once.

This was how I've been going about it in both my playthroughs. Fingers crossed for you bud

[HuntingFever]

This trophy is known to be a little buggy on rare occasions but redoing the relevant missions in Playthrough 2, will fix the problem . If this doesn't work for some reason, your only option is to delete your saves and start over with a new character.

Edited August 26, 2020 by HuntingFever
Update.