Alan, Wake Up trophy - blocked - not popping

[Kevakii]

I literrally finish the game two times on PS5, in maximal difficulty (nightmare difficulty), but this trophy does not pop. 

"New game" or chapter selection, nothing. Has anyone encountered this problem before ? A solution ?

Thanks

Edited August 22, 2022 by Kevakii

[thatguynick]

I have only finished it once on Nightmare, but also having this problem. I wonder if the "Special 1 and Special 2" episodes must also be done on Nightmare for this to pop, although that would be weird as their trophy lists are seperate like DLC.