"That's all I got" not popping

[samy002]

That's the trophy for Ellie's jokes.

The game' help tells me the joke I'm missing is the one in the hotel lobby (Pittsburg). So I went there and triggered the jokes again. Now the game card for that level has disappeared just like if I completed it but the trophy didn't pop.

I'm currently installing the game again. Hope this will help.

[Ringtonwhaledog]

Have you played 'Left Behind' as there are a series of jokes in the DLC that are part of this trophy.

 

The trophy is not the same as original or remastered versions

[samy002]

Yes I played it. I actually have all other trophies except this one :/

If my understanding is correct jokes count as optional conversations and when using Chapter Select the counter shown I've done them all... 

[emailking]

You could try replaying the suburb section or Left Behind section again and trigger the jokes to see if the trophy will pop. If not, I think the only option is to delete your save completely (backup to cloud first if desired) so it forgets that you've heard any of these. Then replay. If you put it on very light and skip cutscenes you could probably get to all of the jokes in Part 1 in like 5 hours and in Left behind in about a hour.

[samy002]

I replayed the 3 spots with jokes multiple times through Chapter Select but still no trophy

I hope they'll fix it and I wont need to replay the whole game without even being sure it'll work...

 

Edit: So I finally got it and the ! My advice would be to follow step by step the walkthrough on Naughty Dog official support page:

https://feedback.naughtydog.com/hc/en-us/articles/8963926179092-That-s-all-I-got

 

Also I was confused bc I couldn't trigger the optional conversations by the graffiti house and the ice cream truck in the Suburbs. Here is the official explanation:

https://feedback.naughtydog.com/hc/en-us/articles/9396811906580-Why-aren-t-certain-optional-conversations-being-triggered-when-I-return-to-Suburbs-to-listen-to-Ellie-s-joke-

Edited September 20, 2022 by samy002
Solved!

[oswald41]

Im having issues I havent got all the jokes yet im halfway there but the trophy progress shows 0% in my trophy list

Edited September 22, 2022 by oswald41

[GrimReaperMakoto]

Sounds like naughty dog can't make this trophy work even on PS5.

[samy002]

59 minutes ago, oswald41 said:

Im having issues I havent got all the jokes yet im halfway there but the trophy progress shows 0% in my trophy list

 

That's not surprising: the trophy doesn't track each single joke (there are 6 jokes in the game). It tracks the 3 locations where jokes trigger:

• Pittsburgh (4 jokes)
• The Suburbs
• Left Behind

So as soon as you complete one location it'll be counted in the tracker as 1/3 

[oswald41]

 

 

2 hours ago, samy002 said:

 

That's not surprising: the trophy doesn't track each single joke (there are 6 jokes in the game). It tracks the 3 locations where jokes trigger:

• Pittsburgh (4 jokes)
• The Suburbs
• Left Behind

So as soon as you complete one location it'll be counted in the tracker as 1/3 

ok im still in pittsburgh i believe so ill check once i complete that part

Edited September 22, 2022 by oswald41

[emailking]

Yeah it's confusing how they did it. I forgot about 1 of the jokes in Pittsburgh and the Suburbs ones wouldn't trigger on my first playthrough. So it was until I got to the Left Behind jokes (which are practically unmissable) that I finally got the tracker to move.

[oswald41]

17 hours ago, samy002 said:

 

That's not surprising: the trophy doesn't track each single joke (there are 6 jokes in the game). It tracks the 3 locations where jokes trigger:

• Pittsburgh (4 jokes)
• The Suburbs
• Left Behind

So as soon as you complete one location it'll be counted in the tracker as 1/3 

ok so i started the suburbs trophy progress now shows 33 percent

[oswald41]

seems the trophy is glitched sort of, just finished the game plus left behind no trophy and progress shows 66% ive read if you move joel during a joke it doesnt register

[zemiguelreis]

Stuck in 66%. What should I do?

 

Edit: checked the activity cards and I was missing one. You need to wait until Ellie finishes all jokes, do not progress until she stops talking. 

Edited December 6, 2022 by zemiguelreis

[Citizenofpanem1]

I was stuck on this too (2/3).  Turns out I missed a bit of the first Pittsburgh joke.  As others have said, make sure you fully complete each dialogue and don’t walk off early.

[Play3GianniGreed]

Wow, three different versions of the game and this trophy is still bugged. 

Excellent work Naughty Dog.